Preparing a small internal audit function for an external quality assessment
Standard 8.4 of the Global Internal Audit Standards is titled External Quality Assessment. It expects the chief audit executive to arrange an external quality assessment of the function at least once every five years, performed by a qualified and independent assessor from outside the organisation. For a team of one to five people this can feel out of reach: the cost, the preparation and the exposure of weaknesses all weigh against it. Preparation is what makes it manageable.
Two routes, and why the choice matters
The Standards allow a full external assessment by a qualified assessor, or a self-assessment with independent validation by one. The second route can cost less and suit a small function, but the validation must be independent and competent, and the conclusion remains the validator's. Whichever you choose, agree it with the board or audit committee and record the decision.
What assessors look for first
- A charter approved by the board that reflects the current Standards (6.1, 6.2).
- Evidence that the function is independent in practice, not only on paper (7.1).
- A risk-based plan and proof that it drives the work (9.4).
- Engagement files with objectives, scope, criteria, evidence, review and clear findings (Principles 13 and 14).
- A quality programme with internal assessments and performance measures, reported to the board (8.3, 12.1, 12.2).
- Follow-up that confirms implementation, not just management's word (15.2).
A practical sequence for a small function
- Run a self-assessment from your files, not from memory, and keep the evidence reference for each answer.
- Review a sample of completed engagements against your own methodology and the Standards.
- Record gaps with an owner, a date and a decision on whether to fix, accept or explain each.
- Tell the board the results, including the weak points, before an assessor does.
- Choose the assessor against written criteria: independence, qualification, experience and no conflicts.
- Make the evidence easy to find: an index that points to each document.
The one-person function problem
A single auditor cannot independently review their own work. The Standards do not excuse the function from review. Record that engagements were self-reviewed, describe what compensating checks exist (a peer reviewer from another function, a periodic outside review, a stricter checklist), and tell the board. Hiding the gap is worse than reporting it.
What no tool can do
No kit, template or software performs an external quality assessment or gives a conformance rating. Preparation tools reduce surprises and save time. The conclusion on conformance belongs to a qualified, independent assessor.
Common questions
How often is an external quality assessment required?
Standard 8.4 expects an external quality assessment at least once every five years, performed by a qualified, independent assessor from outside the organisation.
Can a small function do a self-assessment instead?
The Standards allow a self-assessment with independent validation. The validator must be qualified and independent of the function and the organisation. Confirm the current requirements on theiia.org before choosing.
Does a self-assessment kit give us a conformance rating?
No. A self-assessment identifies gaps and prepares evidence. Only a qualified, independent assessor can give an opinion on conformance with the Standards.
Prepare before the assessor arrives
The QAIP and External Assessment Readiness Kit gives you self-assessment questions, a file-review programme, an evidence index and a gap register.
SEE THE KIT →